the bonebreaker killer documentary. Movies. the bonebreaker killer documentary

 
 Moviesthe bonebreaker killer documentary  #205 Goodnight Sugar Babe: The Vera Jo Reigel Story

00 pm and he was asleep in his bed. Find ratings and reviews for the newest movie and TV shows. Awards & Events. #45. " The. Tortured as Long as Possible. The 13YO That Survived The Famous Bonebreaker Killer. If not for his last victim's seemingly endless amount of resolve and a literal. With Kristen Baumer, Thadius Phillips, Kimball Roundy. Trending. WARNING: Very Graphic!! | The Bonebreaker Killer | Joe Clark WisconsinPatreon: I Use To Stream: When 12 Thadius Phillips met 17 year old Joseph "Joe" Clark, he could have never imagined the sheer torture that he would endure. Episode 239, Oct 18, 2022, 09:00 PM Oct 18, 2022, 09:00 PMSamuel Little, the man the FBI has called the most prolific serial killer in the history of the United States, died Wednesday at age 80, a law enforcement source confirmed to "60 Minutes. Starring: Gil Carrillo, Frank Salerno. 1. The Bonebreaker Case Morbid • Episode 456 When the body of fourteen-year-old Chris Steiner was discovered floating in the Wisconsin River on July 10, 1994, it brought a heartbreaking end to the search for the boy who had mysteriously disappeared from his Baraboo, Wisconsin home a week earlier. – Lyssna på 239: Joe Clark- The Bonebreaker Killer av Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast direkt i din mobil, surfplatta eller webbläsare - utan app. He had a shift at his new job that morning and when his parents went to wake him at 6. Watch. He had a shift at his new job that morning and when his parents. Another teen disappears in an eerily similar set of circumstances just one year later. From true crime documentaries giving audiences all the juicy and maniacal gossip about some of the most sinister cases of all time like in The Playboy Murders, Deathg in the Dorms, and How I Caught My Killer, to deeply moving and stirring looks back at history like in The 1619 Project, Hulu offers a deep dive into something all fans can enjoy. A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. Aileen: Life and Death of a Serial Killer, 2003. In 2013, a Black teenager’s body was found rolled up inside a mat in the gym of his Georgia high school, and despite signs that his murder could have been racially charged, no one was. View full post on Youtube. Baraboo, Wisconsin; July 4th 1994 - A teenager disappears in the middle of the night. A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. . #BONEBREAKERKILLER. The film pieces together a shocking story through interviews with people close to Ridgway, police officers who investigated his case. Social: Tiktok @truecrimeexposedpodcast Twitter. A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. At turns, the documentary touches on the important work being done to combat the serial killings, like the FBI’s Highway Serial Killer Initiative and the Murder Accountability Project. S4. . There’s even more to watch. 1 /11. Release Calendar Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets Movie News India Movie Spotlight. Aah!Sorry! Oh god…And what did your foot l. A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. A man from Kentucky is suing Netflix for using his image without permission in a documentary about a murderer. 1988. occurs in nightmares . Smith was convicted of second-degree murder in 1994 and sentenced to the maximum term of nine years to life in prison. Then the Sheriff’s department. On the 4th July 1994, 14-year-old Chris Steiner went missing from his bedroom in Baraboo, Wisconsin. Listen to The Bonebreaker Killer Podcast on Spotify. Menu. Kidnapped and trapped in a. Thadius was tortured in so much pain on July 29, 1994. Kerri Rawson sees her life in two parts: before and after she learned that her father was a serial killer. What to Watch Latest Trailers IMDb Originals. Another teen disappears in an eerily similar set of circumstances just one year later. Throughout the. In the mid 90s, a whirlwind abduction of a teenage boy led to a tale of a killer's odd obsession with the sound of breaking bones and confessions of past murders. Night Stalker: The Hunt for a Serial Killer: Limited Series (2021)71%. When 12 Thadius Phillips met 17 year old Joseph "Joe" Clark, he could have never imagined the sheer torture that he would endure. For almost 2 days, Thad was brutally tortured b. Chris’ father told police that he checked on his son the night before at 10. So when quiet couple Dennis and Norma Woodruff is found murdered in their own home, it sends. July 31st 1995, Baraboo police department receives a 911 call in which a teenager calmly claims he is trapped in a house and has both his legs fractured. Eventually, though, Thad escaped and was able to notify the police. The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 1 ///512 Awards and Nominations. David Parker Ray. But underneath, we all look exactly the same. . 2000. Trending. Our Boys. A group of friends looking for an extreme weekend, get more than they bargain for when they mistakenly cross the land of the infamous Bone Breaker. On the evening of July 29,. – Listen to The Bonebreaker Killer, Joe Clark by The Squonk & The Hag: True Crime & Scary Stories instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no. Twit. Mosaic. Groggy, scared and confused you follow him t. Documentary about Gary Leon Ridgway, an American serial killer who was active during the 1980s and 1990s. Rate. is a documentary television series produced by NHNZ that aired on Lifetime Movie Network and, as of 2022, can be seen on Court TV . The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 2 ///513 (Podcast Episode 2021) Parents Guide and Certifications from around the world. . A man swims over two miles in strong currents to reach the shore after his fishing boat sinks in the. by breaking his bones. The Grim Sleeper. "I'll Be Gone in the Dark" also focuses on a potential suspect in the rapes and murders — Joseph DeAngelo, who was arrested by. Ross walked her dog, Ruca, along along a dried-out wash in Albuquerque, New Mexico. When Joe Clark was just a teenager, he grew to love a very morbid activity: breaking bones. I Survived BTK (also released under the titles Feast of the Assumption: BTK and the Otero Family Murders and Feast of the Assumption: the Otero Family Murders), is a feature-length, true-crime/horror documentary produced by UNSUB Films and directed by Marc D. Welcome to this week's edition of What A Way to Go, a documentary channel focusing on the true crime stories of some the monsters that prey on society, inter. This is a case. he's still alive?"July 31st 1995, Baraboo police department receives a 911 call in which a teenager calmly claims he is trapped in a house and has bot. 7. Grace is the main antagonist of the 2020 horror film Bone Breaker. The Horrifying Story Of The Boy Who Survived The Bonebreaker Killer. Bonebreaker, as well as Pretty Boy and Skullbuster, avoided being sent through the Siege Perilous along with the other Reavers after being defeated by the X-Men. The Bonebreaker Case. Thad Phillips was asleep on his sofa when he was taken by Joe Clark who would become know as The Bone Breaker. 15, 2023. In between these punishment sessions, he would make Thad watch TV with him, and behave like they. Having previously directed "Zion" and "Untold: Malice at the Palace," documentaries about a wrestler and an NBA arena skirmish. 2018. In July of 1995, Thad Phillips went missing from his family home. This week we take a look at the murder of Chris Steiner and the torture and attempted murder of Thad Phillips, both at the hands of 17-year-old Joe Clark, also known as The Bonebreaker Killer. . Another teen disappears in an eerily similar set of. Thad Phillips and Chris Steiner never expected their interactions with Joe Clark to turn deadly. Find ratings and reviews for the newest movie and TV shows. Born in 1960 and dubbed as the Walk-in Killer and Night Stalker of Los Angeles in the United States, Ricardo ‘Richard’ Leyva Muñoz Ramírez, has been a subject of several movies and a true crime docu-series on Netflix, based on his unthinkable crimes. TV Shows. Get personalized recommendations, and learn where to watch across hundreds of streaming providers. Bone Breaker - watch online: streaming, buy or rent. Chris and Andrew talk to convicted serial killer, and Sinaloa cartel hit. R. ( 2015-01-26) I Survived. Victims tied to Rasmussen. Honeychurch, who was born in Connecticut in 1954, was married twice and had a daughter with each husband. You then wake up outside with a strange boy. . Movies. A family consisting of two parents and their son break into a home, kill the parents and kidnap their daughter. Survival is one of television's longest-running and most successful nature documentary series. Trending. 17-year-old Joe Clark kidnapped 13-year-old Thad Phillips and took him to his house. – Listen to Episode 14: Thad Phillips and The Bonebreaker Killer by Fight or Flight instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no. The Lost Pirate Kingdom. When human bones are discovered in the woods in Schuylkill Haven, Pennsylvania in December 1985, it puts an end to the search for missing 13-year-old David Reed; skull fractures point to murder, but it will be decades before investigators can find David's. . Another day, another true crime documentary on. Search The 13yo That Survived The Famous Bonebreaker Killer buy goods, offerings, and more in your community area. The family had recently moved in. These documentaries pull no. This Netflix docuseries doesn't focus on that. The most egregious example of Netflix’s warped crush on perpetrators is Don’t F**k with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer (2019), a series mainly focusing on animal abuse videos made by Luka. The Killers of Junko Furuta. . A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. Anyone have any links to anymore information or interviews with survivor Thad or anyone involved? The podcast Small Town Murder did an episode on. It documents the crimes of serial killer Richard Rogers. HBO's latest docuseries "I'll Be Gone in the Dark" will premiere on Sunday. . In the early morning hours of July 29, 1995, 13-year-old Thad Phillips is kidnapped by seventeen-year old Joe Clark, a local boy who has snuck into the Phillips' house. #chriscrimediaries #crime. They exhumed Steiners body and it revealed similar breaks Thad had. Felix Unger, Lou Grant, Sam Malone, Robert Hartley: If you’re checking the Killer’s multiple IDs, you’ll find a pile of pop-culture aliases that include characters from. Aug 19, 2021 at 4:00 AM EDT. The Bonebreaker Killer /// Part 1 /// 512 Part 1 of 2 Baraboo, Wisconsin; July 4th 1994 - A teenager disappears in the middle of the night. . 100 Foot Wave. Crazy sick story. After his captors arrest, Thad was able to provide details that lead to solving the disappearance of another boy the year before. – Escucha 239: Joe Clark- The Bonebreaker Killer por Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast instantáneamente en tu tablet, teléfono o navegador - no necesita. “Do I really need to talk about what happened?”September 30th 2005, at her home in Pampa, 10 year old Robin Doan wakes up to a nightmare of gunshots and real. and Bone Crusher to Dallas Austin, Killer Mik. It starts off promisingly enough with an opening stinger clearly cribbed from the Saw franchise. The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 1 ///512 (Podcast Episode 2021) on IMDb: Movies, TV, Celebs, and more. Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan. Investigators suspect he killed two other women, Mary Lou Pratt and Susan Peterson, between 1990 and 1991. The Horrifying Story Of The Boy Who Survived The Bonebreaker KillerJoe Clark's true crime case narrated by chris true crime diaries. Officially, the cause of death was drowning. who is serving 10 consecutive. The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 1 ///512 (Podcast Episode) Details. For the next 43 hours, he would endure pain and torture beyond belief. This three-part documentary series explores the 1960 brutal murders of three women in Starved Rock State Park in LaSalle County, Illinois. Content warning: This podcast con. Select the department you want to search inThe Bonebreaker Killer /// Part 2 /// 513Part 1 of 2Baraboo, Wisconsin; July 4th 1994 - A teenager disappears in the middle of the ni. Menu. Awards & Events. Eventually, though. Still, once the film starts in earnest, it’s one massive shrug emoji. The Bonebreaker Killer /// Part 1 /// 512 . Joe was a friend, a neighbor, a 17 year old boy, but he was also a sadistic killer who was sexually aroused by physically hurting young boys. "Unseen" The Bonebreaker: When a Teen Killer Kidnaps the "Wrong Boy" - The Disturbing Case of Thadius Phillips - UNSEEN (Podcast Episode 2023) - Movies, TV, Celebs, and more. On July 29, 1995, 13-year-old Thad was sleeping on the couch in his new home in Baraboo, WI. The database of executions in the United States of America. The Prostitute Killer. . . Another teen disappears in an eerily similar set of circumstances just one year later. Netflix. . For the next 43 hours, he would endure pain and torture beyond belief. Cleophus Prince, Jr. In the mid 90s, a whirlwind abduction of a teenage boy led to a tale of a killer's odd obsession with the sound of breaking bones and confessions of past murders. On June 30, Netflix debuted its latest big-ticket true-crime documentary, Sophie: A Murder in West Cork, a three-part deep dive into. – Listen to 239: Joe Clark- The Bonebreaker Killer by Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no. Check out the most-viewed moments of 2022, in this compilation from Interrogation Raw!Watch new episodes of Interrogation Raw Thursdays at 10/9c on A&E, and. 1h Powerful documentary about the investigation into a young child's murder. But Baumeister led a secret, murderous life. HBO's six-part documentary I'll Be Gone In The Dark adapted the true-crime novel by the late Michelle McNamara, which explored the violent crimes and the mystery of the identity of the Golden. " He managed to escape and eventually walk again. . HBO’s new documentary, Crazy, Not Insane, answers this question. The films plot made paper seem thicker. A week later. He was not the type to run away, and what happened to him was tol. Where you can watch it: Amazon Prime Video. After two days of torment and two failed. " After enduring two days of unimaginable torment and two failed escape attempts, Thad emerges as the sole survivor. In the mid 90s, a whirlwind abduction of a teenage boy led to a tale of a killer's odd obsession with the sound of breaking bones and confessions of past mur. Currently you are able to watch "Bone Breaker" streaming on Amazon Prime Video. I’m sorry it took us so long. Awards & Events. In 1995, Joseph Clark Kidnapped 13-Year-Old Thad Phillips. Senior TV & Film Reporter (SEO) Netflix's latest true crime documentary Memories of a Murderer: The Nilsen Tapes explores the atrocities of serial. Heuermann has pleaded not guilty to the murders of Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy and Amber Lynn Costello. For the next 43 hours, he would endure pain and torture beyond belief. After his captors arrest, Thad was able to provide details that lead to solving the. . Films viewed August 2020 a list of 34 titles created 09 Aug 2020 Idiots in the Woods a list of 46 titles created 6 months ago. But Steiner's killer was living among them and waiting to strike again. A. . " After enduring two days of unimaginable torment and two failed escape attempts, Thad emerges as the sole survivor. Hold onto something. He was ultimately caught in 2003 and pleaded guilty to nearly 50 counts of murder. There were definitely more serial killers active. The Jeffrey Dahmer Files is unarguably one of the best true crime documentaries of the past decade. He was taken from his home in the middle of the night and was subject to tortures that no human should endure. . In this 2022 documentary from Tubi, Ridgway's crimes are. In 1995, 13 yo Thad Philips was kidnapped from his home by Joe Clark, aka "the bone breaker killer. r/TrueCrimeDiscussion. A six-part thriller about a children's author (Sharon Stone) who gets submerged in a twisting tale of passion, intrigue and deception. True Crime. It was the most disturbing murder case Albuquerque police had ever seen — and it remains unsolved to. Joe Clark was a sadist who enjoyed causing pain to other people. One of Britain’s infamous serial killers and a former police. The Sunset Strip Killer. – Listen to Episode 14: Thad Phillips and The Bonebreaker Killer by Fight or Flight instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no downloads needed. What should have been a. "I was outside and I was being carried," Phillips recalled. Movies. 15 am, he was nowhere to be found. Wisconsin, 1995. . In 1995, 13 yo Thad Philips was kidnapped from his home by Joe Clark, aka "the bone breaker killer. 1. The Bonebreaker Killer /// Part 2 /// 513. Robbed Their Victims of Humanity. . His captor: a schoolmate and notorious teen serial killer known as "Bonebreaker. In segment two, a case of torture involving a troubled youth named Joe Clark and his 13-year-old victim Thad Philips enables investigators to connect Clark to a murder committed a year earlier. Release Calendar DVD & Blu-ray Releases Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets In Theaters Coming Soon Movie. He had a shift at his new job that morning and. YOUR RATING. The Killer Party: Tyler Hadley; 4. Answer. True CrimePatreon - One boy named Chris Steiner had died from drowning. Select the department you want to search in. Trending. . Breaker (2020) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. Powerful Diablo 4 Barbarian Build. " Held captive for almost 2 days, both his legs were broken and ankles were "twisted until they snapped. South Africa’s Creation Studio, which also handled the zombie makeup for the 2016 film Resident Evil: The Final Chapter, designed the look to be distinct from the typical gaunt zombie. This week, Gage will be telling us about a particularly horrid and unusual case. A 19-year-old student is dragged into a car at gunpoint and taken to a basement where she is chained up and sexually assaulted. 43 Hours of Torture: Joe Clark the Bone Breaker The Twin Files 8. Escaped tells true stories about people who've been held captive, imprisoned, trapped and caged, and how they escaped to freedom. We make videos inves. org. He was a true sadist who had a thing for the sounds of snapping and. Listen to 239: Joe Clark- The Bonebreaker Killer and 277 more episodes by Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast, free! No signup or install needed. Fri, Mar 28, 2014. For the next 43 hours, he would endure pain and torture beyond belief. Making a Murderer (2015–2018) Filmed over a 10-year period, Steven Avery, a DNA exoneree who, while in the midst of exposing corruption in local law enforcement, finds. A deep look into the Jeffrey Dahmer case as told by his neighbors and the detective called the infamous murder apartment in a call that “changed his life. Officially, the cause of death was drowning. See production, box office & company info. The Bonebreaker Killer /// Part 2 /// 513Part 2 of 2Baraboo, Wisconsin; July 4th 1994 - A teenager disappears in the middle of the night. The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 2 ///513 (Podcast Episode 2021) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. The "Bloody Benders" Family. Go behind the scenes as murder detectives try to catch a killer in this true crime documentary! Subscribe to Our Life: Trevor McDon. With Joe Mantegna, Paget Brewster, Shemar Moore, Matthew Gray Gubler. Before these crimes and while serving in the United States Navy, Prince was court-martialed in. 2 Aileen: Life and Death of a Serial Killer (2003) DEJ Productions. Originally produced by Anglia Television for ITV in the United Kingdom, it was created by Aubrey Buxton (later Baron Buxton of Alsa), a founder director of Anglia TV, and first broadcast in 1961. The villain in Hill’s original story was patterned after serial killer John Wayne Gacy, who raped, tortured, and murdered at least 33 young men and boys in the 1960s and ‘70s. Vaughn was first, born. With Joe Mantegna, Paget Brewster, Shemar Moore, Matthew Gray Gubler. Release Calendar Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets Movie News India Movie Spotlight. What should have been a fun weekend has now turned into a fight for survival. – Écoutez 239: Joe Clark- The Bonebreaker Killer par Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast instantanément sur votre tablette, téléphone ou navigateur, sans. In 1991, Dallas authorities convicted Charles Albright, also known as the Texas Eyeball Killer, for the murder of Shirley Williams. A very special thank you to Levi for supporting our show as our highest tier patron! Levi’s Adoption Fundraising Page:. . Once there, he began what would be nearly two full days of torture, mostly focused around breaking bones in the boy's legs. . com. 4 1 h 13 min 2020 18+. The family had recently moved in. Joe Clark was himself a teen (17) when he stole Thad from his bed in the middle of the night and he wasn’t a stranger. Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Top 250 TV Shows Most Popular TV Shows Most Popular Video Games Most Popular Music Videos Most Popular Podcasts. Documentary Series. I live right by Baraboo, WI and somehow never heard of this case until I started listening to TCG. Menu. We have a very rare interview with Joe Clark, who has never spoken publicly until now. A group of friends looking for an extreme weekend, get more than they bargain for when they mistakenly cross the land of the infamous Bone Breaker. A Kentucky man is suing Netflix after it allegedly used his photo without permission in a true-crime documentary about a convicted murderer, court documents show. TV Shows. In the mid 90s, a whirlwind abduction of a teenage boy led to a tale of a killer's odd obsession with the sound of breaking bones and confessions of past mur. It looks like we don't have any Company Credits for this title yet. You can. Find ratings and reviews for the newest movie and TV shows. What to Watch Latest Trailers IMDb Originals IMDb Picks. If you need some help deciding what to watch for your next true crime binge, we’ve selected 15 of the best documentary films currently streaming on Netflix . On July 29, 1995, 13-year-old Thadius Phillips was sound asleep in his Baraboo home when something woke him up. Watch on. . Full Cast and Crew. The family owned both a. Often hounding Wolverine at the behest of various employers, Bonebreaker is one of the most powerful foes that has been dispatched by Logan. . According to IMDB Bone Breaker had a budget of around $425,000. A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. Ross walked her dog, Ruca, along along a dried-out wash in Albuquerque, New Mexico. 1. Get personalized recommendations, and learn where to watch across hundreds of streaming providers. Michelle McNamara is the author of the book "I'll Be Gone in the Dark" and the focus of HBO's new documentary series. Be the first to contribute! Just click the "Edit page" button at the bottom of the page or learn more in the AKAs submission guide. He liked the sounds of bones breaking, so he kidnapped young boys and tortured them. No signup or install needed. 101: Betty Gore: Betrayed. . The Jeffrey Dahmer Files. BARABOO (WKOW) -- After being kidnapped by the 'Bonebreaker,' a Baraboo man was awarded at least 21 million dollars. Best of 2022 Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Top 250 TV Shows Most Popular TV Shows Most Popular Video Games Most Popular Music Videos Most Popular Podcasts. Horror. A week later his body is recovered from the Wisconsin River. . . You do not want to miss this brutal tale of a vicious teenager brought to justice. . . Company Credits. What to Watch Latest Trailers IMDb Originals. The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 2 ///513 (Podcast Episode 2021) on IMDb: Movies, TV, Celebs, and more. Police! Thad?In here, it’s me. . What to Watch Latest Trailers IMDb Originals. Capturing the Killer Nurse (2022. Albright was born in 1933, and Fred and Delle Albright, who. . Dennis Rader is a serial killer from Kansas, US. Escaped highlights ordinary people who have escaped extraordinary circumstances: a young boy who was able to escape his bone-breaking captor, and a woman who tricked her captor into freedom after 117 days in captivity. Another teen disappears in an eerily similar set of circumstances just one year later. Menu. Episodes 512&513: The Bonebreaker Killer. . Cuba and the Cameraman. 45m. Not to mention Santa Cruz, a relatively small town with 2 brutal serial killers and a mass murderer within about a year. Clark Told Thad He. For copyright matters, please contact: bosstech148@gmail. Official Sites. Movies. Netflix has an extensive library of feature films, documentaries, TV shows, anime, award-winning Netflix originals, and more. True Crime Garage: The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 1 ///512 (2021) on IMDb: Movies, Tv, Celebrities, and more. 295: [FREE Weekly Episode] The Danny Masterson Rape Case (Part 1 of 2). April 17, 2023 at 3:50 a. It's essentia. October 18, 2022. You've probably heard of Jack the Ripper, an unknown serial killer thought to be responsible for at least five deaths in London in the late 1880s. In early February 2013, he was hitchhiking his way through Fresno, Calif. Marie E. On July 29th, 1994, 13-year-old Thad Phillips was abducted from his own home in the middle of the night by 17-year-old Joe Clark in Baraboo, Wisconsin. Trending. . A man swims over two miles in strong currents to reach the shore after his fishing boat sinks in the. Aah!Sorry! Oh god…And what did your foot l. The Bonebreaker Killer ///Part 1 ///512 (Podcast Episode 2021) Trivia on IMDb: Cameos, Mistakes, Spoilers and more. . Get personalized recommendations, and learn where to watch across hundreds of. Footage from: Cold Case Files: The Bonebreaker (Blumhouse), Escaped - Torture in Suburbia (Kurtis Production), I Survived - Thadius Phillips (Biography Channel), Madison - Wisconsin in HD (David Allen Productions), 2022 Lakefront - Milwaukee News (FOX), Municipal Newspaper (Baraboo News Republic), Getty Images, Audio Network,. Chris Steiner’s case was reopened, his body was exhumed and a post-mortem revealed injuries to his legs and ankles that were identical to Thad’s.